{
  "study_id": "O0-CRP-011",
  "title": "Revelation vs. Derivation: inferential opacity produces a distinguishable attribution signature at matched accuracy",
  "version": "1.0.1",
  "date": "2026-07-27",
  "revision_note_v1_0_1": "Metadata-only revision documenting Python hash() non-determinism in the RNG salt (verdict unchanged, exact effect-size numbers drift by ~±0.3 across runs). observer.py extended with a backward-compatible params override for GAMMA_K/H/U (used by O0-CRP-012). Follow-up study O0-CRP-012 completed on 2026-07-27; the Study B anchor is independently replicated at PRELIMINARY_SUPPORT with fresh seeds 3000..3029.",
  "record_class": "SIMULATION_STUDY",
  "program": "O0-CRP-001 Contact and Revelation",
  "branch": "03_REVELATION",
  "research_status": "complete",
  "evidence_type": "computational_simulation",
  "replication_status": "not_yet_replicated",
  "physical_validation": "none",
  "biological_validation": "none",
  "exploratory_vs_confirmatory": "preregistered_confirmatory",
  "top_line_verdict": "PRELIMINARY SUPPORT",
  "n_endpoints_supporting": 4,
  "n_endpoints_total": 4,
  "accuracy_match_verified": true,
  "verdict_stable_under_robustness": true,
  "source_records": [
    "O0-CRP-001", "O0-CRP-002", "O0-CRP-003",
    "O0-CRP-004", "O0-CRP-005", "O0-CRP-006"
  ],
  "hypotheses_addressed": {
    "primary_alternative": "H2 (Hidden-inference hypothesis)",
    "primary_null": "H0 (ordinary trust calibration)",
    "also_discriminated": ["H1 (Accuracy)"]
  },
  "endpoints": {
    "k_hat": {"d_mean": 2.9976, "r_mean": 4.1731, "cohens_d": 4.408, "p_greater": 5e-5, "support": true},
    "h_hat": {"d_mean": 0.0238, "r_mean": 0.8917, "cohens_d": 53.574, "p_greater": 5e-5, "support": true},
    "u_hat": {"d_mean": 0.0099, "r_mean": 0.2699, "cohens_d": 73.853, "p_greater": 5e-5, "support": true},
    "tai":   {"d_mean": 0.0000, "r_mean": 1.1207, "cohens_d": 4.408, "p_greater": 5e-5, "support": true},
    "a_hat_match_check": {"d_mean": 0.8955, "r_mean": 0.8955, "p_two_sided": 1.0, "match_ok": true}
  },
  "philosophical_provenance": {
    "record": "# The O-0 Phenomenon- A Unified Framework.md (local reference)",
    "section": "revelation vs. ordinary learning",
    "proposition": "Revelation is a distinct cognitive event, not merely accurate testimony.",
    "relationship": "operationalization + partial support in one specific observer model",
    "disclaimer": "Conceptual provenance is not empirical support. The observer used here is a specific computational construction; it may not correspond to any real cognitive system."
  },
  "adversarial_notes": {
    "strongest_remaining_alternative": "The effect is a mechanical consequence of the opacity-hedging hyperparameters GAMMA_K=0.10, GAMMA_H=0.50, GAMMA_U=0.02. Setting them to 0 would collapse the effect.",
    "discriminating_next_test": "O0-CRP-011-S1 — hyperparameter sweep over (GAMMA_K, GAMMA_H, GAMMA_U) to characterize the parameter region in which the verdict holds."
  },
  "replication_queue": [
    {"id": "O0-CRP-011-R1", "type": "fresh_seed", "status": "planned", "seeds": [2000, 2029]},
    {"id": "O0-CRP-011-R2", "type": "independent_reimplementation", "status": "planned"},
    {"id": "O0-CRP-011-R3", "type": "predictive_processing_observer", "status": "COMPLETED", "record_id": "O0-CRP-013", "verdict": "MECHANISM-FLIPPED", "notes": "h_hat and u_hat direction preserved (architecture-invariant); k_hat and TAI direction flipped (architecture-specific to Bayesian opacity-hedge). Study B's mechanism partially generalizes."},
    {"id": "O0-CRP-011-R4", "type": "rl_observer", "status": "planned"},
    {"id": "O0-CRP-011-S1", "type": "hyperparameter_sweep", "status": "COMPLETED", "record_id": "O0-CRP-012", "seeds": [3000, 3029]}
  ],
  "files": {
    "record": "scientific_record.md",
    "preregistration": "preregistration.md",
    "run_script": "src/run_study.py",
    "robustness_script": "src/robustness.py",
    "observer_reference": "src/observer.py",
    "source_reference": "src/source.py",
    "summary_json": "results/summary.json",
    "robustness_json": "results/robustness.json",
    "figures": [
      "figures/01_endpoints_confirmatory.png",
      "figures/02_trajectories_confirmatory.png",
      "figures/01_endpoints_exploratory.png",
      "figures/02_trajectories_exploratory.png"
    ]
  }
}